Call us Today

Local Gold and Silver Dealers in Indianapolis, IN

Indianapolis is the capital and most populous city of the state of Indiana and the seat of Marion County. As of 2017, Indianapolis is considered the third most populous city in the Midwest with a population nearing 900,000.

The site of Indianapolis was selected for the state capitol in 1820 after the Delaware Indians surrendered these lands, positioning the area as the new seat of government. Notably, the name Indianapolis is derived from the State name of Indiana meaning “land of the Indians” or “Indian Land” and “polis” from the Greek word for city.

Having the 27th largest economic region in the U.S., Indianapolis’ diverse economy ranges from finance and insurance, manufacturing, professional and business services, education and health care, government, to wholesale trade. It has also developed a niche in sports and auto racing, being best known for the celebrated Indianapolis 500.

During the mid-20th century, Indianapolis framed itself as a tourism destination for sports, building tennis, track, soccer, and football facilities, which revitalized its business district.

Known also for its philanthropy, Indianapolis has developed a bustling cultural oasis, which includes The Children’s Museum of Indianapolis, hailed as the world's largest, the renowned Indianapolis Zoo, and a host of other historically and educationally relevant sites such as Indiana University-Purdue University, as well as a vibrant public art scene.

Sales Tax on Gold and Silver in Indianapolis

Indiana does not charge taxes on coins, legal tender, or bullion, according to the Indiana Sales Tax Information Bulletin #50.

Local Gold and Silver Dealers in Indianapolis

Coin Shop

Indiana’s Coin Shop specializes in collectible U.S. coins and boasts the largest inventory of proof and mint sets, cents through dollar coins, commemorative quarters, and paper currency coins in Indiana. As a full-service coin dealer, they offer an array of coins, from low to rare, high-grade coins.

(317) 291-1930
4710 W 34th St
Indianapolis, IN 46222

Diamond Stamp & Coin

Diamond Stamp & Coin offers currency, diamonds, gold, and silver, and will buy coins in any condition. The locally owned and operated business has been in operation since 1985.

3440 Shadeland Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46226

Hoosier Gold Buyer

Hoosier Gold Buyer offers a variety of services to coin collectors and precious metal investors, including free appraisals and coin counting. They stock a wide selection of coins (commemorative & proof and mint sets), silver and gold bullion, and buy all forms of gold, silver, platinum, and palladium in U.S. and foreign units, with inventory changing daily.

(317) 702-2075
5038 Kentucky Ave.
Indianapolis, IN 46221

Indy West Coins LLC

Indy West Coins buys and sells high-grade U.S. coins, as well as gold and silver bullion coins, including 40% and 90% silver U.S. coinage, gold bullion, Lincoln cents, buffalo nickels, quarters, proof and mint sets, and more. West Coins is a PCGS and NGC authorized dealer. Their inventory can be found online and on eBay.

(317) 837-9825
1776 Valleywood Dr
Avon, IN 46123

Lost Dutchman Rare Coin

Founded in 1984, Lost Dutchman Rare Coin offers free estimates, while specializing in rare coins, bullion, paper currency, and other precious commodities.

4983 N Franklin Rd
Lawrence, IN 46226

Midwest Jewelry and Coin Exchange

Billed as one of Indiana’s largest buyers, Midwest Jewelry & Coin has helped collectors in the Indianapolis area locate and sell coins for more than two decades. Specializing in precious metals, their inventory includes rare coins, graded coins, silver dollars, and gold and silver bullion coins, jewelry, and watches.

(317) 844-9596
1340 E 86th St
Indianapolis, IN 46240

The Perfect Coin

As an NGC authorized dealer, and a member of the American Numismatic Association, owner David L. Stancel has a reputation for integrity, assisting individual collectors and investors in Indiana, and handling their property.

(317) 696-9140

Universal Gold & Silver

Universal Gold & Silver has been in business for more than 25 years and specializes in buying and selling precious metals including coins, jewelry, and bullion.

Their coin and currency inventory include all types of gold and silver coins, including commemorative coins, U.S. and foreign coins, silver dollars, 90% junk silver coinage, proof and mint sets, and PCGS and NGC graded coins and bullion.

(317) 351-1900
4320 E. 10th Street
Indianapolis, IN 46201

Wheatley’s Coin and Supply

Wheatley’s Coin and Supply offers bullion, U.S. coins, and an extensive selection of coin collecting supplies and publications. Bullion options include the American Silver Eagle, 5 oz silver bars, 1 oz gold bars, and 1 oz copper rounds.

(317) 462-2625
231 W Main St
Greenfield, IN 46140

Thanks for reading our guide to buying gold and silver bullion and coins in Indianapolis, IN. If you know of any other coin or bullion shops in the city of Indianapolis, please contact us at so we can update our directory.